Cyber Monday Moved. Your Budget Plan Should Too.


Question: How do you pace your ad budget for Black Friday 2026?

Direct answer: Export last year's Shopify sales by day (filtered to new customer revenue if you have meaningful repeat business), work out what share of combined November and December revenue each day produced, then move each day to its 2026 equivalent: Black Friday to Black Friday, Cyber Monday to Cyber Monday. Multiply those shares by your combined November and December budget to get a daily spend target, and log actual spend every day so you know whether you're behind. Treat November and December as one budget this year, because Cyber Monday (Nov 30) is back in November and will make month-over-month comps misleading.

Black Friday budget pacing starts with one change this year: Cyber Monday is
back in November, so last year's day-by-day numbers won't line up. Brad Ploch
shows how to map last year's revenue curve onto the 2026 calendar, turn a
combined November and December budget into a daily spend plan, and let an LLM
build the pacing sheet for you from your Shopify sales by day.

Get the pacing template and AI prompt from the episode:
https://www.scalabilityschool.com/get-my-q4-pacing-doc

We discuss:

- Why to plan November and December as one budget in 2026
- Reading your revenue curve by day and by hour for Black Friday and Cyber Monday
- The 2026 Black Friday calendar: early bird Nov 2, promos Nov 23, cutoff Dec 11
- Pushing demand to Amazon after your shipping cutoff
- Using Klaviyo or Omnisend with Claude to pull last year's marketing calendar
- Why CPMs rise but CPA falls over Black Friday
- Building a Black Friday budget pacing sheet with AI
- A $3M example: daily caps, credit limits and tracking actuals
- Plus last year's full pacing and holiday roadmap episode

Get the Scalability School newsletter (free, short, no spam):
https://www.scalabilityschool.com/scalability-newsletter

Last week, why your Meta ROAS will look worse this Black Friday: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WTD00tPyUR4
Zach's $100K Black Friday morning: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX7q1FYlqwE
Learn more: https://www.scalabilityschool.com

This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It’s a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they’re offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you.

Scalability School is a weekly show from Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch, and Zach
Stuck about what is actually working right now in DTC growth. No theory, no
recycled LinkedIn takes, just the numbers and decisions behind real brands and
real ad accounts.

Chapters

00:00 Black Friday budget pacing for 2026: start here
01:20 Start with your revenue curve, by day and by hour
02:53 Cyber Monday is back in November: plan one budget
04:03 The 2026 Black Friday calendar, early bird to Q5
07:26 Why CPMs rise but CPA falls over Black Friday
09:41 Build a Black Friday budget pacing sheet with AI
12:26 Pacing a $3M budget: daily caps, credit limits, actuals
17:17 2025 replay: when Black Friday demand peaks for your brand
23:58 Peaks and valleys around Black Friday weekend
26:54 The Q4 calendar from Prime Big Deal Days to Q5



Full Transcript

(00:00) Hey, is Brad from the future? Just to let you know that Shane, our producer, is going to cut last year's episode to the end of this. I'm going to mention it several times throughout about how you should go. You should check out that other episode. We added it to the end of this one, so you can just watch all the way through and you get the best of both worlds.

(00:14) You can hear what changed this year with what is useful from last year's episode, which went into a bunch more details. So stick around, check that out. And like we said, if you have any questions. Below in the comments. The key to success for Black Friday comes down to understanding when you expect revenue and demand to peak, as well as having a plan to capture that demand.

(00:37) And so in this special Black Friday episode, this additional little YouTube video, if you're not watching on YouTube, you're definitely gonna want to go over to YouTube. I'm gonna be screen sharing. I'm going to take you through the plan that we use to help our clients kind of plan and execute around Black Friday.

(00:50) So first thing that we're going to do is kind of walk through kind of when to expect demand to pick up. And then the second thing that we'll do is look at how you can think about executing this demand or executing on capturing this demand with your marketing strategies and tactics order to maximize the moment.

(01:05) And this this can be the difference between making money and losing money certainly of maximizing the contribution margin, revenue, profit that you want to capture during this moment. So without further ado, let's go ahead and jump in to my sheets. So I'm I wanted to first start by and let me go ahead and zoom in on this thing a little bit here.

(01:23) I wanted to first kind of start by showing I want to start first. Start by showing an example of of revenue and how it occurs. Now there's a couple of different lines on here. Don't worry about the differences between the two lines, but I just want to show you an example for when revenue occurs throughout Q4 for a specific brand.

(01:41) Now what's really important here is this will give you some indication of what this can look like for your brand. What it's not going to do is tell you what to expect for your brand specifically. So for example, if you are a brand that is more gifting heavy, you may see demand pick up more aggressively from Cyber Monday through the shipping cutoff.

(02:01) If you are a brand that maybe has a higher price point and people have been waiting all year for for the sale. You might see Black Friday be substantially bigger. If you're a launch based brand and you have a new collection releasing, or you have a lot of organic, pent up demand that's waiting for Black Friday will probably be substantially bigger than your Cyber Monday.

(02:20) If you are a health and wellness brand, probably have a solid Black Friday and Cyber Monday. But the Q5 moment, which is kind of December 26th through the beginning of the year, is probably going to be much more meaningful. And so what's really important is to understand how your revenue has historically occurred.

(02:38) And the best way to do this is go into Shopify and export to things. Now go to analytics, go to the page where you can export sales by day and export two different versions of that one the total revenue version and two the new customer revenue version, because that's going to allow you to understand both of those curves and how those differ from the new customer.

(02:58) One is important because it's going to allow you to determine how you should be allocating your spend dollars more specifically over this time period. Now you may you may look at total MERS and not just Amr, but my my kind of general take on this is for most brands, looking at when your new customer revenue occurs is going to be the biggest tell of when you should be thinking about pushing budgets.

(03:18) It's kind of my attention that maybe you are listening to this podcast and you've never heard of our new podcast, AI d to see WTF if you're dealing with AI stuff, you're not sure where to go. You're not sure how people are using it. Check out this podcast. It's with two friends of mine that's actually genuinely useful.

(03:36) There are things that we go through. We talk about how we're using AI. It's a really great podcast. If you want to figure out what's happening right now. Indeed to see with AI. So AI D to see W.T. F, check it out on YouTube. Check us out on Spotify anywhere you get your podcasts. Look forward to having you as a listener.

(03:53) Another example in a way to to look at this, this this chart is directly from meta. It's one of my favorite charts. It's a little bit dorky, but this is for all advertisers on their platform. You can see down here source global median advertising rates across purchase optimized ads in all verticals for 2024 through the beginning of 2025.

(04:10) And there's a couple of things to keep in mind. So they have three things charted here, which are CPM, conversion rate and cost per purchase. So what you'll notice is in the blue here CPM starts to spike. And there's there's generally a lot of discussion around does CPM matter. And I think during this time period what you'll notice is that CPM.

(04:27) And I would say that generally this is true CPM is largely a reflection of obviously kind of like the market conditions generally speaking, for for meta, but also kind of customer intent and buyer intent. There's going to be a ton of advertisers pumping their budgets through this time period, and that's going to force CPM to go up.

(04:46) The good news is that because we've all been conditioned to buy things during this time period, what we're going to see is alongside that is an increase in conversion rate. So when this blue line starts to peak kind of into late November and early December, we also see that conversion rate actually goes up faster than than CPM does, which is important for CPA or cause for purchase, which ultimately starts to decline during this time period.

(05:14) Now, what you'll notice is, as you look at this chart, CPA starts to change pretty dramatically. And it's really important that this kind of like general overview is going to be useful for brands to kind of get an average understanding of what, maybe what to expect during this time period. But again, you really want to look at this for your brand, particularly when your revenue occurs.

(05:31) You can also overlay efficiency on top of this. I would again suggest looking at Amer in particular in this case. And so yeah, as you kind of look at this graph, what you'll see is CPM conversion rate. Both pick up into December. They kind of drop into the shipping cutoff. And what meta will suggest is Q5 is a critical time to continue the momentum.

(05:50) What Shirky is you can only do that if you have you know, you can be creative about how you can answer to that, to that moment for your brand. Like maybe there's something that you can do to take advantage of that. But it's difficult if you don't have a business that operates on Amazon or, you know, is in retail, it's going to be really hard to maximize those couple of days before Christmas because you can't you you quite literally can't get the customer product.

(06:10) And that's not that's not your fault. But again, there are ways to kind of be try and be creative about about that. And then CPA. Right? A lot of brands are going to see an increase in CPA at the beginning of the year if they're not in the health and wellness category, if they don't have a new year, new momentum.

(06:26) But what I would suggest that you do is think about, like, is there a way that you can pivot your messaging, your offering, the way that you communicate on your landing page and your ads on your website to fit the moment? That might not be possible for all brands, but something that you could try to take advantage of again.

(06:41) One to start with the numbers, because the numbers are going to tell us really important details about when to start our planning. So my biggest suggestion for you would be going into Shopify, exporting your revenue by day, exporting new customer revenue by day and plotting them on a chart and just seeing what the graph looks like.

(06:59) Obviously you could see that in Shopify too, but if you wanted to add ad spend and efficiency and all that on top of that, then you would be able to to do so by doing that. So from there, let's pop into the calendar, because the calendar is going to allow us to then maximize the peaks that we have on this calendar and try to smooth out the values as much as possible.

(07:19) And I have to give credit where credit is due. Comments. Our collective Taylor holiday. Those folks have done a fantastic job of, you know, really bringing this idea of peaks and valleys to the forefront of the e-commerce discussion, particularly around this time of year. I think they also have some great Black Friday, Cyber Monday material.

(07:34) You just go to the website and search for peaks theory. see one for kind of general the throughout the entire year. And then if you do for peaks of Black Friday, Cyber Monday, they have great resource on that as well. And most brands have a couple of different peaks that happen throughout the year. And so for this brand specifically, there are a couple that are very obvious.

(07:49) So they started their sale at couple of weeks into second week of November. And the reason we did that last year was because the election was the first week of November, and that just threw a little bit of something into the mix. You'll see that over the course of the next couple of weeks, there's a bit of a pullback.

(08:04) And this is this is generally true across most brands. Now you can kind of offset this by having a little bit of a you know, if you start your sale during this time period you can try to offset it a little bit. Maybe you can maximize your email sense. But this is where, you know, there's generally a little bit of pullback, kind of that initial spike in, know, shopping and customer awareness and gift buying will happen at the end of October going into November.

(08:25) So if you're going to start your sale early, that would kind of be the recommendation there. But you kind of just expect to see some pullback leading into actual Black Friday. Now this is kind of the weekend before Black Friday. This is like this this Saturday Sunday and Monday. And again you'll see this when we go over to the planning section.

(08:41) But our general recommendation would be if you've waited to start Black Friday you didn't start it early, then you probably want to go ahead and start it on that Monday to take advantage of kind of some additional initial demand and get a little bit of a spike there, and then you can run it. This is Friday. We always see a pullback from Friday into Saturday and Sunday.

(08:59) Again, you'll see where new customer revenue occurs on that trend. And that's important to pay attention to. Last year we saw less pullback from Saturday and Sunday from Friday into Saturday and Sunday. And so where we usually see if you can see me on the screen where we usually see a big spike on Friday and a big drop on Saturday and Sunday, but still good Saturdays and Sundays.

(09:17) We saw less of a drop on Saturday, Sunday and then Monday. Generally generally spikes as well. Sometimes brand specific though if you change the offer on Monday, that can cause some fluctuations in either direction. So just something to keep in mind is that the weekends do pull back. You want to adjust your ad spend accordingly, and so that's something to keep in mind.

(09:34) And then when Monday rolls around, pull back on the budgets, change things up. Even if you still have your promo live, don't expect that the efficiency is going to continue. It's going to fall off. Look at what it has historically fallen off like for you. Make sure you pull back budgets, make sure you dial things back, and then figure out how you maybe need to reposition your messaging and your offer going into the shipping cutoff stretch.

(09:55) So if you need to pivot to a holiday sale, you need to pivot to a shipping cutoff stretch. You can do that as well. And then try to maximize that kind of pre shipping cutoff threshold. And then there's some of the things that we can do kind of going into the rest of your. So let's go ahead and pop over into the calendar.

(10:08) Because I think the calendar where we're going to start to see some actual or actionable things that we can do from a planning perspective, if if we can make a copy of this and share with you, I definitely will. But here are just some moments that you can try to to do, or try to take advantage of the moments that you see on the calendar.

(10:24) You're trying to come up with a reason for people to buy today, and there are different moments that will happen starting in Q4 that you can try to latch on to and take advantage of them. So the point of this calendar is to force yourself to go look at how your sales have occurred last year and figure out, did I do any of these moments? Can I take take advantage of any of these moments where there might be some kind of natural increase in shopping demand, and how do I maximize that for my brand? And so the first thing that we see here,

(10:50) kind of in October, and this is confirmed, I believe, as at the time of recording this, I record, I tried to record this once and I wanted to come back and give it another shot, and I'm glad I did, because now I think I can say that the Amazon Big Deal Days, which is kind of like their fall Prime savings, will be happening October 7th and eighth.

(11:06) And so a lot of brands during Prime Day, even if they're not on Amazon, will launch something with similar messaging. Obviously, there's IP law around what you can say for, you know, you can't say Prime Day sales during Prime Day because they have that trademark. So be cautious around what you're calling this, but you can kind of latch on to the fact that Amazon will have some, some kind of pushed demand during that stretch.

(11:26) And now if you are an Amazon, obviously you can take advantage of that as well. But this kind of kicks off or gives some kind of initial kick off into the gifting shopping. We see some gifting heavy brands will start kind of the last week of October. They might have a little bit of an early rush, you know, maybe post Halloween when people are kind of done with their, their candy and dressing their kids up.

(11:45) If you have kids and they are just kind of like ready to get into Christmas mode, the Christmas music goes on, Mariah Carey starts to pop off. And so that is just kind of the maybe this is the kickoff to that season in a way. And so you can latch on to that. You can use this moments, whether you're on Amazon or not, and try to make the use of that.

(12:02) If you have something that makes sense for Halloween, you sell candy or costumes or, you know, something that can be tangentially related to novelty, you can take advantage of that to. There's just a little bit of a quick note here on the sale clearance items. If you want to start pushing fall items a little bit more aggressively, or start to maybe consider discounting those who move out some of those items. If you are.

(12:22) If you have some of those in your catalog, you can start to think about doing that around this time period as well. Obviously, then we have Halloween, which if it makes sense for you to maximize that or use that for your brand, you can you can figure out how to work that in. And then from an actual November perspective, you have a couple of different options.

(12:41) so highlights that I have here on when Early Bird should start are going to be specific to your brand. Our recommendation to our clients is generally if you feel comfortable starting November 1st or November 3rd, which is that first Monday in November, you should do that. And so that's going to allow you if you go back and look at the pacing example, the pacing example, and also this the sheet, that's where we're going to start to see some of the momentum pick up.

(13:05) And what you'll notice is if we look at this CPM graph CPM starts to rise here a bit. And conversion rate also starts to rise a bit here. But at the beginning of November it doesn't it doesn't kind of go up as quickly as you'd like it to. And what we generally see is again, that initial kind of pop of gifting, hey, Halloween is done.

(13:22) There's some kind of gifting momentum here that does work pretty well. And then people start to naturally just like pull back and wait because they know Black Friday is coming. And a lot of people want to make sure that they are getting the best deal. Now, the way that you communicate can obviously influence that as well.

(13:36) So my general recommendation, our general recommendation is if you listen to the main podcast version of this, this is kind of like an accompanying episode to that podcast. If you listened to that, if you didn't, you should go listen to it. But if you did, you'll remember that we talked about having a plan, and Zach talked about basically from now through the end of the year, they have a plan for every single day of what they're going to do from a messaging standpoint on their website.

(13:59) And you can take advantage of that. I will reserve comment on what that means for your quote unquote brand. And if you think it's tarnishing to your brand, I'm just telling you what we see from from our perspective, which is if you start if you're going to start early, I would generally recommend starting within the first couple of days of November, because that's going to allow you a couple of extra days to take advantage of that.

(14:17) If you don't feel comfortable doing that for whatever reason, you certainly don't have to just know that if you kind of launch it within that middle range of November, it might not be as as impactful and you might not be able to pull pull as much additional revenue in there. And that's okay, because maybe you can kind of save it and maximize it in the actual week of Black Friday.

(14:35) So then we've got we've got where you could consider starting your early bird, which is maybe you send out an email to existing customers and you say, hey, you're going to get the best deals. We don't want you to be stressed out when you're shopping, so you can buy now and maybe actually give them a little bit of an extra discount.

(14:49) That also coincides with Veterans Day and Singles Day. If you want to take advantage of any of the messaging there, if it's relevant for your brand, we don't have to deal with the election this year. That certainly helps from a CPM and attention perspective more than anything. so that will be that will be nice to just kind of roll right into Black Friday.

(15:05) So if you haven't at this point started Black Friday, you're waiting. Our recommendation would be going ahead and kicking off your Black Friday promo on the Monday before Black Friday, November 24th. And the reason we had suggesting that is, again, it just gives you a little bit of a head start starts to allow you to see which ads are going to work.

(15:23) See if you need to make more of anything in particular and just start to really capture the moment. A lot of brands are starting earlier in earlier, every single year. I think that's the common, common discussion that everybody has. there's there's a lot of value in doing that because allows you to have ads live longer, allow you to see what's what's working.

(15:37) Well, you can kind of capitalize and make more on. And if you have to make a pivot on your offer, which at this point you probably don't want to be making pivots on your offer. But if you have to, you still have a couple of days to consider doing that. Now. Don't expect, don't expect that you can influence demand more than just the macro environment, right? The Monday before is not going to be nearly as big as Black Friday and Cyber Monday for 99% of brands.

(15:59) Now, again, there's some brands with like a pretty big pent up organic demand, and they have a massive email list. They have new product releases that happen on that Monday before they have the ability to do that. But the average brand and most brands will not be able to do that. And so just because your Monday starts a little bit slower than your Friday, again, you can look historically and you can say, great, I've, I've launched on the Monday before, and I've done 20% of the revenue on that Monday.

(16:23) Then I do on Friday. So you can have the same expectation for that going into this year. If you just look at the historical, if you want to get a better average and you have more data to go back on, go look at what the average is for the last several years, and you can just look at them kind of combined. Cool. Don't we have kind of going into Thanksgiving, which is pretty shift forward.

(16:40) Then actual Black Friday kicks off. That's where you know, if you if you need to send additional emails or do something around Black Friday, you can do that. Then you've got going into Cyber Monday. Post Cyber Monday, a lot of brands will just extend their sale. Again. Just because you're extending your sale doesn't mean you should expect that demand will continue.

(16:58) But a lot of brands will do an extended Cyber Monday into Tuesday. They'll use some gimmicky language around. We didn't plan to do this, although every single one of them plan to do this. And maybe that allows you to ride into Tuesday. Alternatively, you could consider gifting Tuesday as a moment to take advantage of.

(17:15) But regardless, if you have a gifting friendly item and a lot of things can be positioned as gifting friendly items, some more than others. Understandably, then this is when you maybe really start to ramp up your gifting messaging. Maybe you pivot to a holiday sale instead of a Black Friday sale, and then you can push there.

(17:31) That doesn't mean that you can't have gifting as live as early as October. I mean, we have brands right now who are planning their gifting ads so that they can go live sometime in October. Now that the way that we structured campaigns is that they won't get spend until the moment is here. And so we just like to have them, you know, ready, whether it's in a cost controlled campaign or it's in a bigger CBO, we're spending just won't force.

(17:53) So we think it's okay to launch sooner than that. Just this is when you can really start to expect that to pick up. And so there are many gifting brands who will have bigger Decembers, particularly because Cyber Monday is in December again this year like it was last year. It wasn't the previous years. You can expect that your December will be bigger than your November if you're gifting heavy.

(18:13) And that's okay, right? Just it's pretty condensed into December 1st through, you know, whenever that shipping cutoff period is for you. But, this is where this is the time to start to push that gifting messaging really heavily. If you've waited for some reason, I would suggest starting sooner than that if you can. Cool.

(18:28) And then we've got, you know, say next day, maybe you can use that to if you have some, some fun little things that could be maybe be used in there. Obviously people need to order that in time for Saint next day. So you know, something to keep in mind with your messaging. Then at some point, kind of around the December 10th ish to 15th ish range, people are going to start to have a shipping cutoff period.

(18:48) And so leading up until that point in your ads, in your emails, and on the website, you want to clearly communicate when the shipping cutoff will be, because that's going to add some urgency into people actually, stopping procrastinating. Now, my great example of this, my my personal anecdote, is my dad goes and shops the two days before Christmas every year.

(19:06) He's never going to be able to buy anything online or as much as he wants to online, because he's just going to continuously procrastinate until a few days before Christmas. And that is just that is just how he rolls. That said, if you can convince some people to shop online, you can do it by saying like, hey, this is this is the last chance to actually get this in time for Christmas.

(19:24) Now, what you might consider is on the website, you can try to, you know, push priority shipping if you want people to get it before Christmas. You can update that that shipping, that the shipping profile and Shopify to actually communicate that like get this, use this to get it before Christmas. If you have shipping estimates on there, just make sure you communicate with your three people or if you're fulfilling it, make sure you know that you can do that.

(19:43) And then just keep an eye on the shipping cutoff for the actual providers. You know, the UPS, the USPS is of the world. The Fedex is of the world. Make sure that they're going to do it. So you're not overpromising there at this point. You can also consider, if you are on Amazon, maybe redirecting some ad traffic to Amazon.

(19:57) I want to speak on, like the efficacy of that, digital gift cards you can try to push. They generally don't work that well. I'd love to see anybody that's crushed. Kind of this period of where our shipping cut off is if anybody is crushing post shipping cut off without Amazon, I would be very curious to see this.

(20:15) But for Amazon heavy brands or brands that have, you know, call it at least 20 to 30% of their revenue, maybe upwards of 50 to 70% of their revenue on Amazon. Amazon really starts to pick up those last couple of days because obviously you can still get things on time. So if you haven't, this is maybe a time to push your email list over there to try and maximize, like the shipping cut off period.

(20:36) If you have discounts, you can also mention those too, but good time to just kind of maximize the Amazon push and just continue to push folks over at Amazon. And then we have a couple of weird days where again, back to the pacing example. We're going to see the pre-Christmas drop off pretty dramatically. It's really hard to, you know, do anything different in that moment just because people's attention are elsewhere.

(20:55) And I would imagine I'd be curious to see some retail sales charts on this. But I would imagine, you know, those last minute shopping in retail situations are probably picking up pretty, pretty meaningfully the kind of week of of Christmas and then post December 25th post-Christmas, that's when you can kick off the new new year, new me momentum.

(21:14) You can pivot over to your sales messaging during that time period. You can use the same day using Black Friday. If it works well, maybe you need to switch it up and make it relevant for the new year, but at this point, you can kind of pivot over and start to kick off your new year new messaging. Again, just like the gifting, you can start it earlier.

(21:31) Just don't expect that it's going to hit massively until Christmas rolls past us. Like that is just the nature of of the macro kind of trends. You know, you can start it early to be prepared, which maybe gives you some time to pivot if you need to. Just don't expect that you're going to hit your, your your revenue peaks.

(21:47) Your profit peaks until those moments actually occur. And then you are off into the rest of the year, and you are on your way to Q5 and into the beginning of of January, which, depending on the brand that you have, can be a bit a bit volatile, especially if you're not pulling back. So just make sure you pull back on your ad spend.

(22:04) So a lot of different tactical things to keep in mind, but wanted to keep this video specifically focused on the calendar, the pacing, and just kind of things to keep in mind. If you would want more tactical insights, just leave a comment on this video and say, we would like more tactical insights about X, Y, and Z.

(22:20) How are you handling this? Just let us know. Let us know in the comments and I'm happy to make follow up. Either buy myself or grab the guys and throw them on here as well, and just speak to the different Black Friday moments, how to maximize it and get as tactical as you would like. So if you'd like a copy of this calendar, we'll figure out how to share with you.

(22:36) Maybe check the description and we'll see if it's there. If not, you can always DHM me on Twitter, and my Twitter may be in the description here as well. So cool. All right. Thank you all. If you have any questions hit me up. Otherwise happy Black Friday and good luck to you. All right, friends, quick break. This episode is brought to you by North Beam, the marketing attribution platform that we love over here at Scalability School.

(22:56) If you're a marketer, I mean, you probably agree, right? Incremental testing is broken. They were. These tests require tons of labor spreadsheets to reference, and the designing of the test is slow and error prone. How are you supposed to know what to test in the first place? Right. There's a million factors that can make incremental testing difficult.

(23:14) But the good news is North Beam has completely changed the game and they fix this. Only North Beam incrementally automates your incremental test design and monitoring, while protecting you from the major mistakes that plague incremental testing. North beam builds tests using your own MTA data, launches them directly in ad platforms, and automatically monitors them throughout.

(23:35) If something threatens validity, you're alerted before it ruins the result. With North Beam, you can launch tests in platform with a single click, saving you tons of time and reducing any chance for errors. And when the test concludes, your results flow straight into your MTA, meaning you can easily see results alongside the rest of your data.

(23:56) Incrementally. Was broken. North beam fixed it. Welcome back to another episode of the Scalability School podcast. I am flying solo today to talk about all things Black Friday once again, kind of redoing my episode from last year where I showed you how to set up your pacing, specifically how to set up your calendar specifically, and if you check the show notes, we are going to provide you a couple of things a link to this calendar, as well as a prompt that you can put into your favorite LM of choice to go ahead and get this sheet set

(24:28) up for you so you can follow along and be prepared for Black Friday. So the most important thing to keep in mind, and I'm going to keep this episode much faster than the episode last year, because I would recommend going back and watching that. It was a very quick episode, and I went through a bunch of the specifics and nuances of the calendar specifically, so I'm going to fly through a lot of that this time around to focus on what are the differences this year and some of the things that I didn't cover in last year's episode,

(24:52) which is going to be specific to budget pacing and how that breaks down. so, like I said last year, the most important thing to be ready for Black Friday is to actually be ready to understand and expect what's going to happen throughout the course of the next couple of months as Black Friday gets underway. It's so for you.

(25:09) What that means is understanding what your revenue curve looks like for November and December. And so the most important thing that one of the first things that I would do is just start by looking, going into Shopify, going into, you know, whatever analytics tool choice you like to use and just looking at revenue day by day.

(25:25) And then over the times like Black Friday or Cyber Monday, actually going hour by hour to understand what should revenue look like, because I should be setting up my paid media plan in accordance with that. And when I find opportunities or valleys or gaps to potentially fill in the gaps with emails or SMS or think about can I change or adjust my offer, potentially can I launch more ads? And then you can find things that you can do in there, but you need to know and understand when things are likely to occur throughout the course of

(25:54) the next two months, so that you can have a plan that backs that up. So first thing that I would do is go into your Shopify or your analytics tool choice. Look at the revenue broken down by day. The next thing I would do is go down and look at it. The hour by hour review for Black Friday and Cyber Monday. So you're not surprised and you're not thinking.

(26:13) They're sitting there thinking, hey, things are slow. Or if you see different peaks that are happening throughout the course of individual hours, then you can go look back. What did I do last year for an email cadence, and how do we make sure that we match that up? So that's the first thing that that I would do from there.

(26:29) The other thing I want to just call out, it's going to be really important to keep in mind. That's different about the last two years. We mentioned this in a previous episode is that Cyber Monday falls in November now. And so you need to be setting up your plans and your comps to adjust for the fact that Cyber Monday is in November, because if you look up or you're working with your CFO or whoever does your books, or you're looking at your analytics who have choice and you're saying, wow, my November was really, really good this year, I'm

(26:53) crushing it, then you're likely to be very disappointed by how your December goes. If you kind of forget to combine and look at those two months holistically together and line up things like Black Friday, because they don't occur on the same day of the year. Whereas obviously a day like Christmas or New Year's does, or, you know, Veteran's Day is another one that is, you know, kind of flexible.

(27:13) So, that's just wanted to kind of hit on those points because that's going to be a bit different this year, and it's going to impact how we think about budget pacing. And so as we pop over to the counter really quick. So first thing to keep in mind is just understanding what your actual pacing looks like. So that way you can be set up for success.

(27:29) And I'm going to show you I'm going to come back to this habit in a second and show you how you could set up your tab and kind of explain how this works, so you can understand and set up daily expectations of what your spend should be. But let's take a quick look and glance at the calendar just to see how things are a little bit different this year.

(27:43) So obviously, you know, as, as as I talked about in this previous episode, you know, there's there's many brands are going to start in November 1st with their sale. And our recommendation historically has been if you have no concerns about doing it, then you should just plan to do it. We saw no downside impact.

(27:58) We didn't see the sale necessarily fatiguing early, especially if you're a brand that's built on new customer acquisition, you shouldn't really have any issues by, you know, scaling and starting your your, your deal early. I don't think it's going to fall on deaf ears for new customer acquisition. If the vast majority of your traffic and revenue is driven by new customers.

(28:16) Now, that's a little bit different. If you are starting to consider the repeat side of this, but kind of focusing primarily on brands who are scaling their paid media acquisition throughout this time period. So we go through kind of suggesting early bird starting as soon as as soon as I'm aware. First to the on away from the first Monday in November, you can go on the second.

(28:33) And then we've got we've got Veteran's Day Singles Day that happens on November 11th, then we've got that that can kind of run through there. And then Black Friday. We're kind of suggesting that Black Friday promos, proper promos start November 23rd. That's going to be the Monday before Black Friday. And they kind of run obviously through Cyber Monday with one consistent offer giving Tuesday up to you if you want to take a break or pivot or do anything during that time period.

(28:57) But then you can kind of quickly pivot into more direct gifting messaging. It's not that you can't use gifting messaging throughout the course of this entire period. You know, people are definitely buying gifts throughout this time, but it's going to pivot much more aggressively into kind of like holiday sale gifting, messaging.

(29:10) Focus around this time period. Then you want to keep in mind and plan for when you're shipping cut off. You know, should be you know, we're working with your carriers to understand that uniquely. Once that happens, if you are on Amazon, what can you do to push traffic over to Amazon for a brand that that we own? We saw that meta ads were able to continue to scale, but all of a sudden the efficiency just looks substantially worse because all of our demand was being captured over on Amazon, kind of post shipping cut off

(29:36) because we told people very transparently on our website, like, you're not going to get this in time. If you want to get it on time, you should go over to Amazon, which would be my recommendation for you as well. We have this different kind of Amazon push here, which is this is like there's a there's a range of people where you can kind of get stuff on time still from the brands here, but at this point, like once you hit the Saturday before, there's a very, very unlikely chance that your carrier from your DDC site is going to be able

(30:03) to get to you on time. Whereas Amazon Prime Delivery still has a really good chance of getting it there, honestly, probably even through the 22nd. But you know, you should be checking on your your brand specific context to keep that in mind. And then usually things go a little bit quieter here. And then we've got Q5 New Year to me, which Mehta loves to talk about, which I will ping over to that in a second.

(30:23) But important context is that you kind of take this templated calendar and you figure out what you want to do with your brand to slot in. What are the what are the specific moments that are going to be happening? What did we do last year? I think that's a really important consideration, is go into your email provider or your marketing calendar from last year and pull all the things you did, dates you started, everything.

(30:42) If you've got, you know, you've got Clavius or Omniscient or whatever, you can connect their MCP to Claude and you can just ask it like, what did I do last year? And how can I make sure that I do those those same things this year if they worked? So that way you're not missing a beat, because missing one email could be the difference between heading your numbers and missing your numbers, or substantially putting additional profit dollars into your pockets.

(31:02) So this marketing calendar then lines up really nicely with what we see from Meta's seasonal chart. Again, I talked about this last year, and these are technically last year's numbers. I don't have a I don't have a refresh one just yet from the meta team, but you can kind of take this into consideration for how you think about spending.

(31:18) So we've got CPM as a blue line. We've got conversion rates as the pink line and we've got CPA as the purple line. Now these things cannot be like they have to be combined together. And actually CPA is probably one of the more reasonable things to look at. But CPM without conversion rate is not a super useful metric in most cases for DTC brands.

(31:39) And conversion rate is not super useful on its own for for most DTC brands as well, because I think the common misconception is that, okay, CPMs are going to go up and that's really bad. But the intent also follows that, and we see that reflected in commercial. It's not like anybody becomes CRO Masters during this period.

(31:55) It's because shopping intent peaks during this during this time period. And you can kind of see that reflected in the CPM chart. So as as CPMs rise, conversion rate follows. And that allows CPA cost per new customer acquisition or cost per acquisition allows that to actually come down throughout this time period.

(32:14) So into into November, you see it start to slowly dip where bottoms out. It kind of around the, Black Friday period. The thing that's missing from this chart that is obviously really important to consider as well, is just like over overall dollars invested into the auction, which is not considered right. Because yes, CPM like lets you know CPA is bottoming out actually here, which looks like it's mid or early December.

(32:40) Maybe that is Cyber Monday in this case, because Cyber Monday was in December and 2024 was a Monday in December of 2024. But you know, you know, it doesn't just continue to drop. Spend is probably dropping substantially from there. Then you can see CPA tends to to kind of peak around New Year looming moments as people just kind of get past the fact that they just blew a bunch of money during Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

(33:01) Unless you are a health and wellness brand in which you have your your real Black Friday starts around this period. So so there's that. So if, if if it felt like I went through any of those things really fast, it's because the like I said, the the last year's episode spends much more time going into the nuances of that.

(33:16) And what I wanted to focus on specifically in this one was getting your budget, pacing, setup and how you could use something like this to your advantage during this time period. So it's relatively straightforward, and that's why I'm going to I'm going to fly through this. But what we'd like to do is look at and again, if you if you use the prompt in the description and you grab this template, which will be there for you, and you upload this to your leg of choice alongside a CSV of your Shopify sales by day.

(33:43) And then you could also do an hourly version of that as well to get your actual like hour by hour spend during Black Friday specifically, which is really important. It'll do it for you, right? It'll do it for you. You should check it and check its mass. But I set it up. I set this up in a way that the LM could, could, could build you your own spreadsheet version, and you don't have to try and export and do a bunch of spreadsheet things, which is different from this time last year.

(34:03) So, that's an AI in a nutshell. Okay. So on the left side here, what you're going to do is you're just going to grab last year's revenue by day. And so I just have a random example brand in here, just kind of random numbers that's anonymized. And so you can see that kind of drops in into here. And it's 2025 in a nutshell.

(34:21) And then we've got the we've got 2026. And what we have to do is we need to adjust Black Friday, Thanksgiving, Cyber Monday for the day that it actually occurs this year. And then obviously we need to readjust for, for Christmas, which we do down down here a bit. And so what you're going to see is you're going to see November and December as a percentage of the total of November and December revenue.

(34:42) Now that's important because we have to play with this change in Cyber Monday year over year. Because because Cyber Monday happens in November this year. We need to consider I like to consider November and December as a total budget for the combined of those two months, because of how much weight Cyber Monday itself has.

(35:00) And then some brands even like post-Christmas, kind of the new year, new me moments. It also has a pretty big moment that's that's worth considering. So this just helps to make sure that you're not, like, totally jacking up your comps. And it gives you a starting baseline for what to expect on the actual day.

(35:15) Right. And so this is this is total revenue from Shopify last year. If you are a new customer heavy brand or you actually have like a decent amount of repeat customer business, what I would what I would suggest doing during this time period is actually filtering this to new customer revenue, because it's going to take out some of those things, like massive email pops, which usually impact retention customers quite a bit more.

(35:39) And it's going to you don't want to be spending into moments where email allowed you to spend more last year, right? You know, you want to consider that. So I would suggest filtering by new customer revenue before you export and give this to your your LLM friend to to build out the sheet for you. But that's, that's, that's kind of how this, this, this bad boy comes together.

(35:56) It takes actual revenue. It tells you what percentage of the total of the November and December this day was. So that way when you push it over to the same day this year, you kind of understand, okay, if I'm at, you know, you can't just take if you're if your budget in this case is $3 million for the course of, you know, this is this is an example for a real brand.

(36:17) You know, they're planning on spending $3 million in this period. They're not going to say, well, I'm going to spend the same day on by Friday. And I don't think anybody like the our community is very sophisticated as pointed. No better than that. This is going to make sure that your pacing is going in the right direction.

(36:30) So that way you're not falling behind because you don't want to be playing catch up, or you don't want to be overspending leading into the moment. And you also want to understand and be underprepared, right? You need to go to your meta rep and make sure that your daily budget allows you to spend $250,000 a day.

(36:42) If you're going to be ramping up to this or your credit limit is is set up in a way where you know you're not going to hit a credit cap issue when you get into this period. So you have to know what this looks like for a bunch of different reasons. So, again, you're going to drop in these numbers or your, your, your cloud bots or whatever is going to drop in these numbers for you, and then it's going to push out a suggested budget here.

(37:02) Now the really the only inputs that you need to give are plug in the budget here. So your your plan combined budget for November and December. If you have one you can obviously use revenue in the same way. But because we're using budget pacing for this, we just put in budget and then we know what our goal is. We know what our efficiency targets need to be on a monthly basis.

(37:20) So I could just add an efficiency, you know, a efficiency column to this as well. But you can use revenue like you can swap this for revenue. There's no reason you have to use ad spend budget. But in our case we're trying to understand how much we should be spending. And so that's why we that's why we do that. Then you have this section to plug in the actual.

(37:33) Again, no need to actually feel like you need to use this, but it'll kind of tell you how much you're off and the difference that you're building up. So do you need to play catch up and try to catch up on your budget, pacing and a bunch of different stuff that kind of explains this. So, this is what we use. This is what we use.

(37:47) We use something like this. For the last several years, obviously, AI has made building these substantially easier and also keeping them updated substantially easier. But I think it's really important to like manually input these and check it every single day so you know if you are behind or not. And in this case this brand is growing substantially.

(38:04) They're going to spend as much this year or more this year on Black Friday than they made last year on Black Friday. And so we need to be prepared to spend into that moment by having this plan in place. Now, there's a little bit at the bottom here, which just kind of like helps you kind of think through the math of like how many days are actually happening for Black Friday? Obviously there's only four from the Friday to Monday, but then from the shipping cutoff, they actually end up being the same amount of days,

(38:24) which is great because Friday the 11th is a Friday, which kind of impacts that. But then how many, how many days are there post shipping cutoff? How many days are there pre cutoff which in years past were substantially different. The the biggest thing that happens this year to keep in mind is that Cyber Monday happens in November.

(38:39) So you just want to account for that. So yeah pretty straightforward. If you have any questions as you're going through this of course, feel free to leave a comment and we will be happy to do this. But yeah, my biggest recommendation here would be make sure you have a plan. Copy the template, go to the LM drop in the template here, drop in your Shopify sales by day and allow it to fill the sheet out.

(38:59) Then go back and forth with the LM to build out your plan and make sure that your sheet is fully dialed in and then updated every single day. And go back to last year's episode and watch it. Because I went in way more detail about how you can be prepared for the moment, how you can build a calendar, when to push, when to pull, different things that you can do throughout the period.

(39:14) And if you haven't watched any of our episodes from this year or last year, and you're just looking to binge content on Black Friday or Cyber Monday, all of our Black Friday Cyber Monday content is extremely tactical and gives you examples of what Zach was doing to push $100,000 revenue hours throughout the course of the period, so if you have any questions, leave a comment.

(39:31) We'll be happy to help. Otherwise, thanks for tuning in and we will see you next week. The only way that we grow this podcast is by you sharing it with your friends. Honestly, like reviews kind of don't really mean anything too much anymore. They're really meaningful, but they don't do a lot for the growth of the podcast.

(39:49) And so sharing YouTube links, sharing Spotify links, sharing Apple, whatever we call it under the podcast app now, anything you can share, the better we're going to be. Guys, anything else you want to say on this? Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube. Rack up those views for us. We'd love to see it and then subscribe.

(40:07) Make sure to subscribe on YouTube as well. And I relentlessly refresh the YouTube comments because it dictates my mental health for the day. So please say something nice about all of us. Thank you everyone. Thanks for listening. Honestly.

Made With AI

Next
Next

Your Meta ROAS Will Look Worse This Black Friday